The backhoes
and dump trucks have done their jobs, and Eden Hall’s campus is beginning to
take shape. The field lab buildings are
erected and the amphitheater, a structure intended to foster
university-community relationships, is built.
Sustainable design from the ground up.
Yet, the digitally-rendered designs of the Eden Hall campus that appear
in admissions literature are still a far cry from the facilities that exist
there now. The original buildings to the
property are thus far, the only functional ones. Looking at the Master Plan for the campus, I
can’t help but think of the striking disparities between the hundred-year-old
buildings occupying the landscape now and the futuristic-looking design of the
buildings to come.
The campus,
as it is now, is an old estate. Situated
across the road from the construction site for the new buildings, the farmhouse
features tall ceilings on the main floor, perhaps 25 feet in height. Wood floors adorned with oriental rugs
compliment the vintage furniture nicely.
Passing through the atrium, one enters the dining room in which I
imagine Sebastian Mueller and his wife, Elizabeth Heinz Mueller, once sat at
the large table together, separated from the kitchen by thick walls, as their
servants attended to their needs. The
dining room now evokes emptiness. Perfect
place settings amidst a deserted home. There
is no one to eat at the table or prepare food in the small kitchen. The farmhouse is uninhabited, although it is
used.
Upstairs,
the bedrooms have been converted into professors’ offices. Wi-fi is installed but the lead in the glass
windows gives one an eerie, distorted frame through which to view the outside
world. The claw-foot tub in the bathroom
echoes of antiquity and chic, modern design.
Like many old estates of its kind and time, the farmhouse features two
sets of stairways. Having the two
avenues through which to travel up and down does not really have a practical
function. The home is not large enough
to justify needing separate sets for the east and west wing.
Rather, they
serve as a reminder to the modern observer how deeply entrenched in society are
values and attitudes associated with class, status, race, and gender. Of course in America, the land of opportunity,
everyone has the chance to climb to the social ladder with hard work. Yet, Mueller’s servants certainly used their
own set of the stairs in his home—the ones in the background which can only accommodate
for single file traversing and look plain compared to the intricate woodwork of
the main stairway in the foreground of the home.
Ironically
perhaps, Mueller was a strong advocate for working women, and when he died in
1938, he willed the estate to be a retreat resort for the women factory
employees of Heinz. The values we
associate with country life such as fresh air and open spaces no doubt were
valued first by factory workers embracing the chance to escape the smoggy city.
The lodge
sits opposite the old farmhouse. It’s
where the working women would stay on their vacation. On the second floor, in between the current
classrooms equipped with high speed internet, projectors, and screens, are
small bedrooms featuring two twin-size beds per room, made with white sheets
tucked into hospital corners. I entered
the bathroom upstairs one day after class and opened the door to what I
presumed was a toilet stall only to find a shower. Funny how when some aspect of your environment
clashes with your expectations of that place and it catches you off guard.
History has
a funny way of refusing to be ignored, its stories infiltrating our daily
lives, its secrets remaining, however silently, in the creaky narrow stairs in
the back of the estate. The past infuses
itself with the present. Heinz needed to
find a recipient for the Eden Hall property and in thinking about this donation,
they considered its history, originally owned by a women’s rights advocate. Chatham’s historical commitment to advancing
women’s education resulted in the donor finding a match.
The plan for
Eden Hall, once implemented, will embody the 21st century ideals of
sustainable living—renewable energy systems, on-site wastewater filtration
using constructed wetlands, and on-site sustainable agriculture to feed the
learning community. But the campus will
also echo its semi-forgotten past, remaining an isolated haven in the country,
an escape from the day to day rush of city living, a novelty perhaps in the
minds of some. An example of how
tech-savvy sustainability is super-attractive, but it can’t happen without the
generosity of many donors. Can Eden Hall
serve as a model for universities and communities across the country? Not unless every one of them has deep
pockets. How can this model inform the
solution for Pittsburgh’s rolling blackouts as energy demands exceed the supply?
Ironically
perhaps, Chatham’s flawless design is deeply flawed in that it cannot feasibly
be replicated. Like the Heinz retreat,
Eden Hall will evoke an ideal and set a standard of what can be achieved with
the proper resources. I am left
wondering about vacations and sustainable initiatives:
Can we create meaningful employment in which
workers do not need to escape from their daily lives but can relish every
minute of it?
Can we promote systemic change over and above
individual efforts to re-envision sustainability? Would our elected representatives put
policies in place to alleviate the cost associated with transitioning to clean
energy, environmentally-friendly construction, water conservation, and
small-scale agriculture?
I hope that
Chatham’s institutional initiatives can transcend idealism and promote demands
for national-level change instead of perpetuating the myth that individual
choices and actions will rescue society from eminent doom.
The
farmhouse is still there, still reminding us of the not-so-distant past and the
mountains of work needed to create the future that we want.